Which is better - Blade or Mallet Putter?
The first step is to confirm you want a blade putter over a Mallet putter. There is no right or wrong and much will come down to personal preference and to an extent, your putting style.
A lot of traditional players prefer the feel and look of the blade putters that, despite a few advancements, have been the norm since the origin of golf. While materials, weighing, and other features have evolved, the look of a modern blade putter is comparable to those used for centuries.
Mallet putters come in a variety of designs and shapes but are larger with more body behind the face of the putter. The design allows for better perimeter weighting and a number of them find it to be more forgiving and easier to use. Before you commit to purchase, give some serious thought to which style you prefer.
Most Popular Blade Putter On Tour – Comparison Chart
7 Top Rated Blade Putter Reviews
★ Top Pick ★
1. Callaway Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter
Callaway produces some of the top putters in the market, and their Odyssey line is at the top of market.White-hot Pro 2.0 putter is a showcase as to why they are at the top.
There are many different head shapes to select from and it can be overwhelming. You can choose between standard grip or Jumbo grip and that makes it easy to look at this putter.
The reviews do point out how great the putter feels off the face and the sound is just plain satisfying for players.With 200 reviews on Amazon and a 4-star rating, the putter has proven itself as the best in the market.
➽ White Hot insert improves feel and sound off face.
➽ Laser milling insert improves consistency.
➽ Weight placement on the face gives more forgiveness whether on heel or toe.
➽ Alignment aid for better accuracy to hole.
➽ Different head shapes to select from.
➽ May not have your preferred head shape.
➽ Might feel too soft for some golfer’s taste.
★ Also Great ★
2. Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa Putter
This blade putter is a fair investment coma most golfers that play regularly make the sacrifice given the potential performance it offers as well as impressive and sleek looks.The Callaway putters were popular for some time and the Odyssey is the top putter on tour right now. They come in a wide variety but for those that favor a blade design, this is the best option.
The main aspects of Odyssey put a lot of effort into balance and weight distribution. The first way they did it is with an ultralight Stroke Lab shaft. The graphite shaft allows them to save as much as 40 grams which helps them to reposition weight to other areas for better performance. The shaft is stiff for better control.
The weight added to both ends of putter adds to smoothness and control it has to offer. Odyssey has focused on another area that is facing Technology. The putter features multiple micro hinges on the face for consistent and smooth roll with a fair amount of topspin. Most find it to offer great distance control and accuracy.
➽ Good control and consistency.
➽ Superb feel.
➽ Impressive design and looks.
➽ Light graphite shaft allows for forgiveness.
➽ Rather expensive.
➽ Some users faced delivery issues with incorrect grips supplied.
★ Budget Pick ★
3. Cleveland Huntington Beach Collection #4
Cleveland used precision deep face milling in diamond pattern to provide this putter constancy and a soft and pleasing feel. Head is made from 304 stainless steel that adds to the precision and feels and is also highly durable.
It does not hurt that the combination of Engineering and materials leads to what most consider a stylish and sleek look. More advantage of the material is that it allows for customization. The Lie angle can be adjusted by 4 degrees either way.
The recent advancements by Cleveland have put them as the leading putters and are a popular option with amateurs as well as professional golfers.The putter has both vertical and horizontal slight lines but few players are disappointed that they don’t extend to the face front. This is not an issue for many.
Besides the design, quality materials, and Engineering, this putter is very affordable. For the people who want a blade putter with a soft feel, the beach collection #4 is a worthy option.
➽ Soft feel
➽ Delivers a good roll
➽ Accurate and consistent
➽ Smart sleek design
➽ Good sound and feedback
➽ Customizable Lie angle
➽ No sightlines on the front of the face
➽ Softness may take some time to adapt to
★ Our Pick ★
4. Bettinardi Golf 2019 Queen B5
Very few golfers argue that this is a spectacular looking putter. The performance matches excellent looks and is a popular well-loved putter. It is more expensive than the average blade putter but you get a lot of performance and impressive equipment.Sleek and elegant head is crafted from solid pieces of soft Carbon Steel.
The precision face milling uses unique honeycomb design. This was the brainchild of Robert J Bettinard and delivered outstanding consistency and control with the firm’s enjoyable feel. The ball rolls off the face with accuracy.The design works well for golfers with an arc stroke but most blade putter fans enjoy the performance of the Bettinardi Queen B5. It is responsive and has a pleasing feel.
Going back to looks, the face milling is distinctive and the champagne silver finish is impressive. This is complemented by hand-painted detailing in white and Tiffany blue.
There is white alignment aid which stands out and works well for most. This putter is popular with a lot of players, both amateurs and many professionals. It is the choice for many of the leading golfers on the PGA and the LPGA.
➽ One-piece soft carbon steel face
➽ Honeycomb design precision milling
➽ Good control
➽ Assertive ball roll
➽ Responsive feedback and a pleasing sound
➽ Rather pricey
➽ A few find the head to be bulky
★ Our Pick ★
5. Pinemeadow Golf Regular Black Zinc Style Putter
Pine Meadow has to win the top prize in the affordability category. This is a good quality blade putter at rock bottom price. Pine Meadow hail from Portslade, Oregon, and has been around since 1985. You will not see any fancy marketing campaigns or flashy sponsorship deals and this is the main thing that helps to keep costs down.
When they do their own research and development they copy or clone equipment that has proved to be successful. This is common practice but something pine meadow does especially well. This putter is a clone of Ping Classic Style putters.
It has a similar design and PineMeadow does not cut costs on material quality. One can expect a similar performance to the original pink putter. It is made from zinc alloy and diecast. The result is a soft feel and easy roll.The putter has bold and effective alignment aid for better accuracy. The low profile of the blade helps in alignment and centering the ball at address.
Most users agree that it provides good control. The standard shaft is a steel 125 gram Apollo shaft and PineMeadow covers the putter with a 1-year warranty.If you have a tight budget but you want a quality putter that is well designed and well made this is definitely one to look at. While top golfers invest a bit more, this putter should perform well for putters at all levels.
➽ Outstanding value for money
➽ Good design
➽ Well made with quality materials
➽ Decent alignment aid
➽ Low profile
➽ Soft feel
➽ No brand name bragging rights
➽ Not all players love the grip
★ Our Pick ★
6. Wilson Harmonised Golf Putter
Wilson is a well-established golf equipment brand with more than a century of experience. There is a lot to appreciate about this putter besides highly affordable prices. It shows you can get quality blade putters without breaking the bank. The putter looks good, performs well, and comes at a great price.
The putter is heel-toe rated and the face features a polymer insert with many microinjections. This gives it a soft and consistent feel that many appreciate. It has a plumber hose to help it address and distinct alignment aid. The majority of golfers find it easy to swing and very forgiving.
The slightly oversized grip is effective and comfortable with the vertical seam. It works well even in the wet. Besides being a budget putter, this works well for most players at all levels of game.
➽ Remarkable value of money
➽ Soft and pleasing feel
➽ Good balance
➽ Effective alignment aid
➽ Comfortable grip
➽ Some found that it lacked consistency
➽ Not as durable as expensive putters
★ Our Pick ★
7. Ping Vault 2.0 Dale Anser Platinum PP60 Putter
While blade putters are not as forgiving as mallet options this is a true exception. It is forgiving across the entire face of the putter. As it is one of the more expensive options many agree it is worth the investment.
Custom weighting is another advantage and that is readily seen effectively applied in putters. It allows you to dial the putters in according to your specific putting strength and style. For many, it improves accuracy and distance considerably. This with the other technologies used adds to the cost and improves the performance of the putter.
Another feature that makes this putter effective is the precision milled face that incorporates Pings True Roll Technology. This gives it greater consistency and forgiveness. The face is made of 303 stainless steel and gives good feel and responsive feedback as well as pleasing sound. This is what is expected from Ping and the Vault 2.0 PP60 does not disappoint.
The different Technologies work well together to deliver a customized putting experience that helps many golfers on the green. The putter has a comfortable grip and comes with a quality magnetic protective headcover.
➽ Exceptional forgiveness across the entire face
➽ Soft pleasant feel
➽ Custom – weighting
➽ True Roll technology
➽ Highly durable
➽ Comfortable grip
➽ Magnetic headcover included
What to Look for in Blade Putter?
There are several reasons people choose a blade putter over a Mallet putter. Let’s look at the main factors to be considered before making a decision.
The feel of a putter is hard to define and varies from person to person. It is related to balance, weight, materials, and design, and other factors. It is a personal preference and some players find the feel of a putter better than others. There’s no doubt that some putters have better designs and a grip that fits the hands better.
There are face materials or inserts that create a softer feel for all that use them. A number of factors come into play. One advantage of blades is slim simple design which offers better feel than many Mallet putter. This is why they are so popular.
Forgiveness is associated with drivers, irons, and other clubs, it is also related to putters albeit in a different fashion. Forgiveness in putter refers to how the putt works out when you strike it near the toe or heel. A more forgiving putter will deliver fair distance and accuracy in these cases. Blade putters are not as forgiving as most Mallet putters, some offer a lot more forgiveness than others.
The main aim of a good putter is to get an accurate and consistent roll. You do not want any lift or bounce when the ball is struck as it can lead to loss of accuracy and control. The design and face of the putter are important. Face milling and inserts help with the quality of the ball roll.
A Weakly balanced putter is likely to twist as you strike the ball and this naturally reduces the effectiveness and accuracy of the shot. The positioning of the weighting and hosel largely determines the balance of the putter.
Many modern putters have a face insert. They will have a direct impact on the feel and delivery of the putter. Some are designed for a soft feel whereas others deliver a hard roll. This is again a matter of personal preference and related to your putting stroke.
The hosel design is a matter of personal preference. Some help certain styles of putting. What is important is you feel confident and comfortable while addressing the ball on the green. There are different Hosel designs including popular offset hosel. Offset hosel ensures your hands are forward when you address the putt and promotes square face that should improve accuracy. There is no perfect answer and it depends on your putting stroke on what works for you.
The grip on the putter is just as if not more important than grip on your driver and other clubs. Modern grip designs offer comfort and allow for optimized grip for better results. Not only the design of the grip is important but the thickness is also relevant. Some will benefit from a thicker grip whereas others will find more control from thinner grip.
As with all clubs and golf equipment, prices range from highly affordable options to rather expensive. Big brands spend a lot of money on design and research and often a vast amount on marketing and sponsorship. They use advanced materials and workmanship. There is a quality blade putter to suit any budget.
A factor that is worth considering is the number of times the average golfer uses the putter relative to the other clubs in the bag. It is used way more often it makes sense to spend a bit more and invest in a putter that works well for you. It is the easiest way to reduce your score and improve your results.
Extensive research was conducted to bring the very best blade putters in 2020. You should have a good understanding of what to look for when choosing the ideal option for your needs as well as the details of the most popular options available now.
While they are all good blade putters, one came out as best of the best. Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa Putter is a tour-proven blade putter that works well for the average golfer. You may have to dig a bit deeper to invest in this but it offers a great feel and consistency and control. It has a great shaft and is very forgiving. To add to performance advantages also happens to look impressive.
Give some thought to the needs as well as the budget to find the best blade putter for improved accuracy on the green and resulting in lower score for each round.